തിരുനബി (സ) യുടെ തലമുടിയും വിവാദമുണ്ടാക്കുന്നവരും

Xncptijn¸pIÄ ; hnaÀiItcmSv Nne Imcy§Ä

Xncp\_n(k)bpsS Xncptijn¸pIÄ (BkmdpIÄ) ]hn{X§fpw BZcn¡s¸tS­XpamWv. AhsIm­v _dIs¯Sp¡epw tcmKia\w tXSepw CkvemanIamWv. AYhm CXv \ntj[n¡Â  AXns\ A\mZcn¡epw A\nkvemanIhpamWv. _dIs¯Sp¡p¶Xn\pw ]pWy¯n\pw th­­n \_n(k) t\cn«v klm_namsc G¸n¨ XeapSnbpw aäp tijn¸pIfpw kzlm_nIÄ hfsc BZcthmsS kq£n¡pIbpw tcmKia\¯n\pw Cl]cPohnX hnPb¯n¶v D]bpIvXam¡nbXn\pw FÃm CkvemanI {]amW§fnepw sXfnhp­v. 

aZo\m ap\Ædbn A´yhn{iaw sImÅp¶ Xncp\_n(k)bpsS duftbmS\p_Ôn¨pÅ apdnbn AhnSps¯ Xncptijn¸pIfn NneXv kq£n¡s¸Sp¶p. dufmico^n¶v Npäpw {]hnimeamb aknPnZp¶_hnbpw AXn\p NpäpapÅ s{]uVamb ssaXm\hpw \ap¡v ImWmw. At\Iw tImSnIÄ sNehgn¨p hnIkn¸n¨v Ah kwc£n¨v hcp¶ alm\mb A_vZpà cmPmhpw `cWIqShpw apkvenw temI¯v F¶pw _lpam\yaÀln¡p¶p. ]ptcmKa\ {]Øm\§sf¶ t]cn Ckveman \hoIcWw \S¯p¶hÀ¡v iAvtd ap_mdInt\bpw aäv Xncptijn¸pItfbpw BZcn¡p¶Xpw Ah sIm­­v _dIs¯Sp¡p¶Xpw Hcp \ne¡pw JÞn¡m³ IgnbnÃ. tIhew km[mcW a\pjy³ am{XamWv apl½Zv \_nsb¶pw AhnSps¯ apSnt¡m Ip¸mb¯nt\m aäp tijn¸pIÄ¡m Hcp {]tXyIXbpw Csöv hmZn¡p¶ _nZCIÄ¡v, ]s£ Xncp\_n(k)bpsS hnbÀs¸Sp¯v D½kpssew(d) kpKÔhpw acp¶pambn D]tbmKn¨Xpw, A\kv(d) Xncp\_n(k)bpsS XeapSn shůnen«v tcmKia\¯n¶v IpSn¡pIbpw P\§Ä¡nSbn hnXcWw sNbvXncp¶Xpw JmenZv _v\pheoZv(d) Xncp\_n(k)bpsS XeapSn sXm¸nbn Xp¶nt¨À¯Xpw aäv \nch[n sXfnhpIÄ¡pw ap¼n D¯cw ap«n ]n³amtd­­n hcp¶p..

B XncptIi¯nsem¶v tIcf¯nse¯pI F¶Xv aebmfnIÄs¡m¶S¦w B\µZmbIamWv. hyIvXamb k\tZmSv IqSn aq¶v apSnIfmWv Imc´qÀ aÀIkn kq£n¡p¶Xv. cs­®w UÂlnbnse _dIm¯o kmZm¯o§Ä hgnbpw H¶v A_qZm_nbnse tUm. AlvaZv JkvdPn hgnbpw e`n¨XmWv. kzlm_nIÄ apX Im´]pcw A_q_¡À apkvenbmÀ hscbpÅ ssIamä tcJ aÀIkn kq£n¡p¶p­v. Cu iAvdv ap_mdIv BZc]qÀÆw kq£n¡Wsa¶pw AXn¶v Npäqw kuIcy§sfmcp¡Wsa¶pw AÃmlphn¶v C_mZ¯v sN¿p¶Xn\mbn hnimeamb akvPnZv \nÀ½n¡Wsa¶pw kq¶okaqlw Xocpam\n¡pIbpw 40 tImSn cq] sNehv {]Xo£n¡p¶ akvPnZn\pÅ {]hÀ¯\§fmcw`n¡pIbpw sNbvXp.

temI¯n\v apgph³ ImcpWyambn«ÃmsX A§sb Rm³ \ntbmKn¨n«nà \_ntb F¶mWv AÃmlp hnip²JpÀB\neqsS \ÂIp¶ ktµiw. AhnSps¯ t\cn ZÀin¡m³ `mKyw e`n¡m¯ tIcfob¶v AhnSps¯ XeapSnsb¦nepw ImWm³ `mKyw e`n¨m AXv AXnal¯mWv. AhnSps¯ icoc¯nsem¶v kv]Àin¡m³ `mKyw e`n¡m¯ aebmfn¡v AhnSps¯ XeapSn kv]Àin¨ _dI¯m¡s¸« shÅsa¦nepw icoc¯n tNÀ¡m³ `mKyw e`n¡p¶Xv AhnSps¯ ImcpWyamWv. D¡mk(d) Xncp\_n(k) X§fpsS icochpambn Xsâ icocw tNÀ¡m³ {ian¨ kw`hhpw kzlm_nIÄ Xncp\_n(k)bpsS hpfpshSp¯ shůn\mbn Xnc¡v Iq«nb kw`hhpw aäp [mcmfw sXfnhpIfpw apkvenw temI¯v CÆnjbIambn \nehnencns¡ Xncptijn¸pIsf \ntj[n¡p¶Xn¶v ]n¶nse {]tNmZ\sa´mWv?

lÖ¯pÂhZmC XeapÞ\w sN¿p¶ Xncp\_n(k)bpsS sImgnªp hogp¶ apSn\mcngIÄ¡pth­n A\pNc·mÀ aÕcn¡p¶Xp Xm³ t\m¡n \n¶p F¶v A\kv (d) ]dbp¶p. Hcp L«¯nÂ, H¶pw c­pambn apSnbngIÄ Xncp\_n (k) Xs¶ AhÀ¡nSbn hoXn¨p \ÂIn. ]ns¶ A_qXzÂl(d)sb hnXcW¨paXe G¸n¨p. incÊnsâ heXp`mKs¯ apSnIÄ FÃmhÀ¡pambn hnXcWw sNbvXpsh¶pw CSXp`mKt¯Xp \_n(k) A_qXzÂl (d)¡v kz´ambn \ÂInsb¶pamWv asämcp \nthZ\w. thsdmcp \nthZ\¯nÂ, Ipd¨p`mKw A\kv(d)s\ G¸n¨psIm­v "D½¡v sIm­pt]mbn sImSp¡pI' F¶p \_n (k) I¸n¨Xmbpw ImWmw (_pJmcn, apkvenw)

Dkvam³ _v³A_vZpÃ(d) ]dbp¶p. "Fsâ IpSpw_w Fs¶ Hcp shŸm{Xhpambn D½pkea(d) bpsS ASpt¯¡b¨p. AhÀ "Pp PpÂ' F¶p t]cmb Hcp shÅns¨¸pambn h¶p. AXn Xncp\_n(k)bpsS ]pWytIiw kq£n¨ncp¶p. BÀs¡¦nepw It®tdm atäm ]änbm D½pkea_ohnbpsS ASpt¯¡p shŸm{Xhpambn Ab¡p¶ ]Xnhv A¶p­mbncp¶p. Rm\m shÅns¨¸nte¡v kq£n¨p t\m¡n. AsXmcp sN¼n¨ apSnbmbncp¶p.'(_pJmcn)

hr²]nXmhn\p ImgvN XncnsI¡n«m³ bpkp^v (A) Hcp Ip¸mbw sImSp¯b¡p¶ kw`hw hnip² JpÀB³ A[ymbw 93þmw hN\¯n ]dbp¶p­v. B Ip¸mbw apJt¯mSp tNÀ¯t¸mÄ bAvJq_v (A)\p ImgvN XncnsI In«nsb¶v hnip² JpÀB³. AXntesd AXnibw, Cu Ip¸mbw CuPn]vXn \n¶v ]pds¸«t¸mtg¡pw \m\qdv ssa AIse I³B\n Ignbp¶ bAvJq_v (A)\v Ip¸mb¯nsâ DSabpsS hmk\ In«n¯pS§nbXmWv (hN\w 94). Pufn¡Sbn t]mbn {_m³UUv jÀ«v hm§n sImSp¯b¡pIbà bqkp^v \_n (A) sNbvXXv. D]tbmKn¨ncp¶ Hcp ]g¦p¸mbw sImSp¯b¡pIbmbncp¶p. Nn´n¡p¶hÀ¡v CXn Zrãm´ap­v.

Xm_nDIfn {]apJ\mb C_v\pkoco³(d) A_oZv(d)hnt\mSv ]dªp. “Fsâ ssIhiw A\kv(d)hn \n¶v e`n¨ Xncp\_n(k)bpsS Hcp XncptIiap­v”. At±l¯nsâ {]XnIcWw C§s\bmbncp¶p. F\n¡¯csamcp tIiw e`n¡pIsb¶Xv Cu temI¯pÅ kÀÆkzhpw e`n¡p¶Xnt\¡mÄ CãamWv. (klolp _pJmcn) Npcp¡¯n Xncptijn¸pIÄ ssIamdn ssIamdn Ah C¶pw temI¯nsâ hnhn[ `mK§fn kq£n¨pw BZcn¨pw hcp¶p­v. temIapkvenwIsfm¶S¦w AXv AwKoIcn¨n«pw tIcf¯nse Nne ]p¯\mib¡mÀ¡v Zln¡p¶nÃ. AhÀ¡v Xncp\_nsb km[mcW¡mc\m¡ntb aXnbmIq F¶ hminbmWv.

@        tIhebpIvXn sIm­v CkvemanI hnizmkmNmc§sf hnebncp¯nb tImfanÌv A_vZpà ssIsh«vImcpsS ]{X¯n \_nX§fpsS BkmdpIsf \oNamb `mjbn \nµn¨v FgpXnbt¸mÄ At±l¯nsâ {]hmNI\nµs¡Xnsc tIcf apkvenwIÄ {]Xntj[n¨p. F¶n«pw ]{X¯nsâ FUnäÀ ]n. tImb A_vZpÃsb \ymboIcn¨v teJ\sagpXpIbmWv sNbvXXv. hnip² JpÀB\n AÂ_Jd kqd:bn \_nXncpta\nsb km[mcW a\pjytcmSv s]cpamdp¶ t]se A`nkwt_m[\w sN¿cpXv F¶v ]Tn¸n¡p¶p­v. CXv \ntj[n¡m\mhptam? km[mcW a\pjytcmSv t]mepw ]dbm³ ]mSnÃm¯ hm¡pIftà A_vZpà {]tbmKn¨Xv?

@        \_nX§fpsS Xncptijn¸pIsf _dIs¯Sp¯ almcY·mcpsS Ncn{Xhpw, X_dpIns\ AwKoIcn¡p¶ hnip² JpÀB\nse Bb¯pIfpw NmSn¡S¶v AYhm Ah bpIvXn¡v tbmNn¡m¯Xv sIm­v AwKoIcnt¡­Xnà F¶mWv “ssIsh«v cm{ãob¡mcpsS” ]{X¯nepw tijw _nZCIfpsS Hcp hn`mK¯nsâ ]{X¯nepw FgpXnbXv. BXvaobXbpsS t]cn Ckvemw hncp²À \S¯p¶ X«n¸nt\mSv apkvenw hnizmkmNmc§sf XmcXays¸Sp¯n BXvaob NqjWw F¶mtcm]n¡pIbmWv AhÀ sNbvXXv. kzÀ¤w Xcmsa¶v ]dªv Xncp\_n(k) aZo\s¯ ]Ån¡v th­n ]ncnshSp¯ kw`hhpw Xncp\_n(k)bpsS _dI¯m¡s¸« Xp¸p\oÀ IeÀ¯nb shÅw km´z\¯n\mbn \ÂInbXpw AhnSps¯ hnbÀ¸v tcmKia\¯n\mbn klm_¯v D]tbmKn¨Xpw D½pkÂa(d)sb t]mepÅ \_n(k)bpsS A\pNc·mÀ XnctIian« shÅw hnXcWw sNbvXXpw aäpw _pJmcn, apkvenw t]mepÅ {]amW§fnep­mbn«pw apkvenwIfpsS t]cn PoÀ®X Btcm]n¡p¶Xv icnbmtWm ?

@        temI¯nsâ hnhn[ `mK§fn _dIs¯Sp¯p sIm­ncn¡p¶ Xncptijn¸pIÄ \ntj[n¡p¶XneqsS CkvemanI hnizmk¯n¶v FXncmhp¶ BibamWv AhÀ {]Ncn¸n¡p¶Xv. sX¶n´ybnse {]ikvX CkvemanI Iemebamb shÃqÀ _mJnbm¯p kmenlm¯n kq£n¡p¶ XncptIiw ap¡nb _dI¯m¡s¸« shÅw Ime§fmbn hnXcWw sNbvXp hcp¶p­v. \qäm­pIfmbn Imivaocn XncptIiw kq£n¡p¶Xn\mbn \nÀ½nXamb ]ÅnbpsS t]cv Xs¶ l{k¯v _m akvPnZv (XncptIi ]Ån) F¶mWv. ap³Ignªpt]mb almcY·mscms¡ AwKoIcn¨ C¯cw kÂIÀ½§sf \oNamb coXnbnn hnaÀin¡p¶hÀ Ckvemansâ i{Xp¡Ä¡v ]cnlkn¨v Nncn¡m³ Ahkcw \ÂIpIbmWv.

@        Imc´qÀ kp¶n aÀIkn e`n¨Xv Xncp\_n(k)bptSXà F¶mWv C. t{KUv kp¶nIfn NnecpsS hmZw. A_qZm_nbnse tUm. AlvaZv JkvdPnbpsS hiw Xncp\_n(k)bpsS XeapSn Ds­¶v ]gb Ime¯v ]dªXv t]mepw AhÀ ‘hngp§n’. JkvdPnbpsS ho«n kq£n¡p¶ apSns¡«v F¶pw]dªv GtXm apSns¡«nsâ t^mt«m D­m¡n CâÀs\änepw AhcpsS ]pkvXI§fnepw {]Ncn¸n¨v P\§sf h©n¨p. CuPn]vXv {Kmâv ap^vXn ssiJv Aen PqapA t]mepÅ At\Iw temtIm¯c ]ÞnX·mcpsS km¶n[y¯n ]cky thZnbn sh¨v iAvtd ap_mdIv k\Zv hmbn¨p tI«n«pw Im´]pcw hntcm[¯m Xncp\_n(k)bpsS XeapSnsb \nµn¡p¶Xnse A]ISw F{XbmWv? aÀIkv kt½f\¯ns\¯nb ssiJv Aen PqapAsb Hcp Znhksa¦nepw X§fpsS Øm]\¯nsâ ]cn]mSnbn kw_Ôn¡m³ Im´]pcw A\phZn¨nà F¶v ]dªv D­m¡nb ]pInepIsfm¶pw P\w ad¶n«p­mhnÃ. BscXnÀ¯mepw h©\ {]Ncn¸n¨mepw kXyhnizmknIÄ apgph\pw AwKoIcn¨p hcp¶XmbmWv \ap¡v ImWm\mhp¶Xv.

@        Im´]pcw IÅ{]NcW§Ä \S¯n km¼¯nI NqjWw sN¿p¶p F¶mtcm]n¡p¶ Pa. Ckveman¡mÀ¡v Xncp\_n(k)bpsS Xp¸v\ocv sIm­v ssJ_À bp²thfbn Aen(d)hnsâ sN¦®v kpJs¸Sp¯nb kw`hw \ntj[n¡m\mhptam? km[mcW a\pjycpsS Xp¸Â sIm­v sN¦®v kpJs¸Sptam? Akm[mcWamb Nne {]tXyIXIÄ Xncp\_n(k)¡v AÃmlp \ÂInbn«ps­¶v Ncn{Xw km£n \nÂt¡ AXv \ntj[n¡p¶Xv Ckvemansâ i{Xp¡Ä¡v hfw sh¡pIbtÃ?

@        A_q_¡À kn²oJv(d) Xncptijn¸pIÄ¡v ]Ånbp­m¡nbXmbn ImWp¶nÃ. klm_namcpw tijw h¶ alm·mcnemcpw Xncptijn¸pIÄ¡v ]Ånbp­m¡nbn«nÃ. AXn\m Ct¸mÄ Im´]pcw D­m¡p¶ 40 tImSnbpsS ]Ånbpw sXämb BNmcamsW¶v ]dbp¶ atä hn`mKw _nZCIfpw akvPnZp¶_hnsb hsc A\mZcn¡pIbmWv sN¿p¶Xv. Xncp\_n(k) A´yhn{iaw sImÅp¶ dufm ico^v kµÀi\hpw AhnsS sN¶v A´y{]hmNI\v kemw ]dbepw AhnSp¶v adp]Sn kemw {]Xo£n¡epw AXnt\mSv NpäpapÅ akvPnZpÈco^n \nkvIcn¡epw apkvenansâ ISabmWv. AhnSps¯ Xncptijn¸pIÄ kq£n¡p¶Xnt\mS\p_Ôn¨v ]Ånbp­m¡p¶Xv GXSnØm\¯nemWv A\mNmcamhpI ?

km[mcW Cu¨bptSbpw tX\o¨bptSbpw Xp¸Â Hcpt]msebÃ. H¶v tcmKap­m¡p¶Xpw asäm¶v tcmKia\hpamWv. tX³ tcmKim´n \ÂIpsa¶v hnip² JpÀB³ hyàam¡p¶p. AXv AÃmlphnsâ HuZmcyamWv. sshVqcyw IÃmsW¦nepw \mamcpw AXns\ Isöv hnfn¡mdnÃ. cXv\sa¶mWv ]dbmdv. AXnsâ Hcp X·m{XbmsW¦nepw AXn\v {]tXyIX Ipdbp¶nÃ. km[mcW IÃnt\¡mÄ Xnf¡hpw {]tXyIXIfpw \ÂInbXn km[mcW IÃv Akqbs¸«n«v ImcyanÃ. temI¯n¶v apgph³ im´nbpambn h¶ apl½Zv apØ^(k) ae¡Ã, tZh\Ã, Pn¶paÃ. ]s£ Akm[mcW a\pjy\mWv. AhnSpt¯¡v AÃmlp HuZmcyambn [mcmfw {]tXyIXIÄ \ÂIn. AhnSps¯ icoc¯n\pw hm¡n\pw Aaqeyamb {]tXyIXIfmWpÅXv. CXv \ntj[n¡m\mhnÃ. Ncn{Xw km£nbmWv. {]amW§Ä sXfnhmWv. \_n(k)sb km[mcW a\pjy\m¡pÅ X{X¸mSn BJndhnPbw \ãSp¶Xv kq£n¨mepw.

CkvemanIv IĨd ^ut­j³ Hm^v C´y

Pn²